The Sconi

The housing market in Madison, Wisconsin, faces significant challenges as demand continues to outpace supply. The median price for a single-family home in the area reached $470,800 this spring, making it difficult for many families to afford. Despite being surrounded by flat, buildable farmland, development is often hindered by local regulations and community resistance.

Kurt Paulsen, an urban planning professor at the University of Wisconsin and member of the Middleton Plan Commission, noted that "housing dies the death of a thousand cuts." He explained that local officials impose conditions on developments that result in fewer and more expensive homes. These decisions are influenced by residents who prefer less traffic and higher-end neighbors.

Chad Lawler, head of the Madison Area Builders Association, mentioned that some communities actively resist growth. "There are communities that have decided they just don’t want to grow," he said. This resistance adds to existing challenges such as labor shortages and high interest rates.

Comprehensive plans set boundaries for new development but can be redrawn if desired by a community. However, public meetings often attract residents opposed to new housing due to concerns about traffic and crime. As a result, even within designated areas, development can be stalled.

Despite these obstacles, metropolitan Madison remains attractive due to job growth outpacing home construction over the past two decades. Paulsen highlighted a recent success where Middleton approved a subdivision on 128 acres of farmland with homes priced in the $400s. This project could help alleviate pressure in the housing market through a process called "filtering."

Paulsen also pointed out innovative solutions like those seen in Sheboygan County where manufacturers sponsor starter-priced houses for employees. Such initiatives could encourage plan commissions to support growth if businesses advocate for housing availability.

"If the Chamber of Commerce is there saying, ‘Yes, yes, yes,’" Paulsen stated, "that gives growth some support."

Patrick McIlheran serves as Director of Policy at the Badger Institute.

For permissions regarding Badger Institute articles or photographs use or reproduction contact President Mike Nichols at mike@badgerinstitute.org or 262-389-8239.