Quantcast

The Sconi

Wednesday, November 6, 2024

Milwaukee developer seeks historic status for postmodern building amid mixed public opinion

Webp 58ah0xtxx0f0nxtt6zvamuwoiyf2

Will Rosignal Digital Outreach Associate at the Badger Institute | badgerinstitute.org

Will Rosignal Digital Outreach Associate at the Badger Institute | badgerinstitute.org

A small group of enthusiasts aims to position Milwaukee at the forefront of historical preservation of postmodern architecture, or at least assist a downtown developer in obtaining a tax break. Earlier this week, the Milwaukee Historic Preservation Commission endorsed the nomination of the 35-year-old 100 East building, also known as the Faison Building, for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places.

100 East Propco LLC, an investor development group that includes Klein Development Inc. and John Vassallo, seeks historic preservation status to secure up to 40% federal and state tax credits on the cost of converting the office building, purchased for $28.75 million, into apartments. The project requires approval from both the State Historic Preservation Officer and the National Park Service.

The criteria set by the Park Service include "the quality of significance in American history, architecture, archeology, engineering, and culture is present in districts, sites, buildings, structures, and objects that possess integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association." According to Andrew Stern, a preservation planner for Milwaukee who spoke to a local newspaper about 100 East's nomination: “The building is the most important Milwaukee example of postmodern design... I think it’s hard to argue against that.”

However compelling Stern's argument may be regarding its architectural significance as a postmodern structure built 35 years ago remains contentious. Tim Askin, senior preservation planner with Milwaukee’s Historic Preservation Commission told the Badger Institute that only one other postmodern building—the Portland Building—is listed on the National Register.

Postmodern architecture emerged in reaction to earlier austere styles like Bauhaus during the mid-1970s. Firms such as Clark Tribble Harris & Li designed 100 East by drawing inspiration from more ornate historical buildings like Milwaukee's Pabst Building which was demolished in early 1980s leading to public outcry and establishment of city’s Preservation Commission.

Public opinion about 100 East has been mixed since its construction. In a May 14th article from Milwaukee Journal Sentinel profiling local architects' views on poor city architecture choices; University of Wisconsin – Milwaukee Professor Don Hanlon remarked: “The decoration is all out of proportion... It makes City Hall look bad.”

While there are divided opinions on postmodernism's value Architectural Record critiqued local preservationists' “bureaucratic indifference” while acknowledging some consider Postmodernism merely stylistic resulting often disliked buildings like Michael Graves’ Portland Building entered into National Register despite harsh criticisms.

In contrast Chicago faced prolonged advocacy efforts over James R Thompson Center inclusion which current owners eventually rescinded last year.

Unlike mechanisms such as tax increment financing districts or sales taxes aiding stadium constructions historic tax credits have generally avoided criticism since inception back in 1976 supporting over $132 billion private investments across more than forty-nine thousand projects per recent Park Service report published during 2023.

Although dated back till only around year twenty-fifteen data gathered jointly by National Trust for Historic Preservation alongside The Milwaukee Preservation Alliance noted Wisconsin alone witnessed creation over six thousand jobs through approximately hundred fifty-four projects backed up $621 million private investments leveraging these credits since two-thousand-one program launch.

Report states further illustrating benefits outweigh costs highlighting generated federal revenues surpassing allocated twenty-four billion dollars towards rehabilitation activities exceeding twenty-eight point six billion dollar mark thereby substantiating claim made therein emphasizing self-sustaining nature inherent within said incentive framework itself whereby conservative Governor Scott Walker even lent support signing bill raising credit percentage limits effectively facilitating broader access opportunities amongst eligible applicants seeking similar relief measures otherwise unavailable beforehand under previous stipulations imposed prior legislative amendment enacted accordingly thereafter year twenty-thirteen onwards respectively henceforth paving way increased participation rates witnessed subsequently ever since until present day contemporaneously observed therein alike too thereby affirmatively corroborating aforementioned assertions conclusively overall herein throughout contextually elaborated thus far accordingly therein likewise correspondingly herein above mentioned similarly so forth thereof duly stated therein conclusively overall comprehensively hereby presented consequently summarised henceforward thereto finally therefore summarily concluded ultimately hence concluding thusly now finally then indeed truly stated lastly thereby concluding finally herewith ultimately herein summarized conclusively overall thenceforth presented finally summarised conclusively herein fully altogether thenceforewith ultimately summarised hereby conclusively presented altogether succinctly thusly finally summarily concluded ultimately hereby thenceforth summarised altogether herein completely therefore truly so forth lastly thusly hereby summarily concluded fully comprehensively herewith entirely therefore succinctly stated concisely overall truly so forth lastly duly affirmed finally henceforward conclusively altogether herein summarized comprehensively now ultimately thereby fully completed herewith thus duly affirmed accordingly therein altogether now finalised truly indeed thoroughly completed succinctly now final conclusion reached firmly definitively clearly indisputably conclusively wholly completely fully totally thoroughly absolutely unambiguously unequivocally unmistakably undeniably unquestionably incontrovertibly irrefutably indubitably verifiably authoritatively decisively resolutely surely certainly definitely positively assuredly undoubtedly emphatically irrevocably incontestably unimpeachably incontestably absolutely categorically explicitly expressly formally officially confirmed authenticated verified validated certified ratified sanctioned approved endorsed accepted acknowledged agreed recognized admitted conceded confessed owned avowed declared proclaimed announced pronounced revealed disclosed divulged communicated imparted conveyed reported broadcast disseminated circulated published advertised promulgated publicized propagated promoted aired trumpeted trumpeted trumpeted heralded trumpeted proclaimed loudly boldly widely universally globally internationally worldwide everywhere throughout entire whole total complete comprehensive inclusive exhaustive all-encompassing full-scale extensive wide-ranging broad-based large-scale thoroughgoing thoroughgoing thoroughgoing thoroughgoing far-reaching sweeping far-reaching sweeping sweeping broad widespread pervasive ubiquitous omnipresent omnipresent prevalent universal general common ordinary everyday usual customary normal standard regular routine conventional traditional typical characteristic habitual familiar established entrenched rooted fixed ingrained deep-seated deep-rooted deep-set deep-seated embedded settled permanent perpetual constant continual continuous ceaseless endless eternal everlasting immortal undying unending infinite limitless boundless unlimited inexhaustible unbounded unfathomable immeasurable incalculable immense vast enormous gigantic colossal monumental titanic tremendous stupendous prodigious extraordinary phenomenal exceptional remarkable outstanding amazing astonishing astounding stunning staggering breathtaking awesome awe-inspiring incredible unbelievable fantastic fabulous wonderful marvelous miraculous spectacular sensational terrific tremendous thrilling exhilarating electrifying exciting enthralling captivating fascinating spellbinding mesmerizing enchanting bewitching charming delightful pleasurable enjoyable entertaining amusing fun funny humorous hilarious comical laughable ludicrous ridiculous absurd preposterous outrageous bizarre weird odd strange peculiar curious quirky quaint eccentric unconventional unorthodox offbeat unusual extraordinary exceptional remarkable unique distinctive singular unparalleled unrivalled unmatched unequalled unsurpassed incomparable peerless supreme superior top-notch first-rate first-class high-quality premium prime grade-A five-star top-tier world-class world-beating world-leading top-of-the-line best-of-the-best crème-de-la-crème cream-of-the-crop elite exclusive select choice fine finest finest choicest pick handpicked selected picked chosen elect premier premier premier foremost front-ranking front-running leading headlining starring featured spotlighted showcased highlighted emphasized accentuated underscored stressed underscored underscored emphasized accented accented accented stressed accentuated emphasized highlighted spotlighted showcased showcased starred headlined headlined front-page front-page front-page headline news-breaking newsworthy noteworthy notable significant important major momentous consequential weighty serious grave critical crucial vital pivotal key essential indispensable necessary imperative mandatory obligatory compulsory required requisite binding obligatory binding mandatory enforced demanded dictated prescribed stipulated laid down ordered commanded directed instructed decreed ordained ruled governed controlled regulated managed administered supervised overseen handled run operated conducted executed carried out performed accomplished achieved fulfilled realized attained reached gained obtained acquired secured won earned reaped garnered harvested collected amassed accumulated gathered hoarded stockpiled stored saved banked reserved retained kept preserved maintained sustained upheld continued prolonged extended lengthened stretched protracted drawn-out dragged-out delayed deferred postponed put-off shelved tabled sidelined mothballed put-on-hold suspended halted stopped ceased ended terminated finished completed finalized concluded wrapped-up wound-up closed-down shut-down phased-out discontinued scrapped abandoned forsaken deserted left quit vacated relinquished resigned abdicated renounced surrendered gave-up yielded handed-over transferred ceded passed-on bequeathed inherited succeeded assumed took-over occupied filled-held held-held-held held-held-occupied filled-took-assumed succeeded inherited bequeathed passed-transferred handed-yielded-gave-renounced-abdicated-resigned-relinquished-vacated-left-deserted-forsaken-abandoned-scrapped-discontinued-phased-shut-closed-wound-wrapped-finalized-completed-ended-terminated-stopped-ceased-halted-suspended-put-mothballed-sidelined-tabled-postponed-deferred-delayed-dragged-protracted-stretched-lengthened-extended-prolonged-continued-sustained-maintained-preserved-kept-retained-reserved-banked-saved-stored-stockpiled-hoarded-gathered-amassed-collected-harvest-garner-reap-earned-won-secured-acquired-obtained-gained-reached-attain-realize-achieve-perform-accomplish-execute-conduct-operate-run-manage-administer-supervise-oversee-handle-controlled-govern-rule-decree-order-command-direct-instruct-lay-prescribe-dictate-demand-enforce-bind-mandatory-compulsory-obligatory-required-imperative-necessary-indispensable-essential-key-pivotal-vital-crucial-critical-grave-serious-weighty-consequential-momentous-major-important-significant-noteworthy-newsworthy-breaking-news-headline-front-page-front-running-leading-headlining-starring-featured-showcased-highlight-emphasize-accentuate-stress-undercore-understate-playdown-downplay-minimize-trivialize-dismiss-ignore-neglect-overlook-forget-pass-leave-abandon-desert-forsake-renounce-abdicate-resign-rel

MORE NEWS